Following the collapse of the republic, a critical question arises: Can those individuals who were part of the corrupt structure of the republican system—and directly contributed to its downfall—serve as a viable alternative to the current interim government? The answer to this question is quite clear and evident.
The dark figures and groups that gathered under the umbrella of the fallen republic have lost the Afghan nation’s trust. They were manipulative and sold out. If we analyze the situation based on realities, we find that under a centralized authority, the Afghan people will never accept such incompetent, corrupt, and failed political leaders. They lack a credible political vision, leadership capability, and public support. Their return to power would only lead to another collapse.
Looking briefly at their past misconduct reveals a dark and shameful history of corruption. Over the past twenty years, the very individuals who now portray themselves as resistance figures, exiled presidents, and champions of freedom were the leading actors of the corrupt republican regime. They burdened the nation with tyranny and foreign occupation, indulging in tribalism, corruption, and countless unethical practices.
Despite unprecedented political, financial, and military support from the West, these corrupt faces not only failed to build effective public institutions, but also showcased the worst forms of theft, fraud, nepotism, and ties with foreign intelligence agencies.
According to Transparency International’s 2020 report, Afghanistan ranked 165th out of 180 countries in the Corruption Perception Index. This dismal ranking was a direct result of the bribery and corruption committed by these very individuals. Corruption and looting were so deeply rooted in the system that they flowed like blood through its veins. Influential families had captured key government positions and treated national resources as their personal inheritance.
During the past two decades, billions of dollars flowed into Afghanistan from the United States and its allies. However, most of it ended up in the pockets of corrupt officials or was wasted on ineffective projects. The general public remained trapped in poverty and insecurity, while a small elite class reaped the benefits of foreign aid.
In the downfall of the republican system, not only were these corrupt officials responsible, but foreign invaders were also complicit. To protect their interests, they empowered thieves and warlords as leaders, ministers, politicians, ambassadors, governors, and commanders. Though they were fully aware of the extent of the corruption, they turned a blind eye and took no serious action to eradicate it and take serious action against them.
The former corrupt officials—who failed to preserve a stable system and whose corruption first weakened and then destroyed the foundations of governance—are in no way qualified to once again rule Afghanistan. Those who have already been tested and failed must not be given another chance. The future of Afghanistan should not be entrusted to those responsible for decades of misfortune.
Note: The articles, essays, and comments published by the Voice of Hindukush only reflect the views of the authors & writers and do not necessarily represent the agreement of the Voice of Hindukush.
